Decision Making using Probability (Investigation)

Probability calculations may seem like an abstract concept, one which might only be useful to Maths Teachers and Gamblers. After all, who else needs to calculate the probability of rolling two even numbers in a row, or drawing a heart and then a diamond from a pack of cards? 

Probability is used by many other people in may other areas, however, and we will explore some of these occurrences of probability.

 

How probability can save lives: Medical testing

Doctors use probability regularly in deciding whether it is worth "screening" patients for medical conditions. Screening refers to testing people who do not have any symptoms, just in case they have a disease which could be treated. Whilst screening can be life-saving if used correctly, it can also go terribly wrong if used in the wrong circumstances.  

Screening for cancer

A key example is the use of tumour markers to check if someone has cancer. For example, imagine that around 1 in 10000 asymptomatic people have pancreatic cancer, and there is a blood test which is 99\% accurate in detecting pancreatic cancer. 

1. If you do this test, and you get a positive result, what do you think your chance of having cancer is?

Most people answer 99\%. After all, the test is "99\% accurate" right? In fact, the answer to this question is only around 1\%. How can that be possible? It all comes down to probability. 

To see how this works, imagine 10000 people who get tested for pancreatic cancer. Statistically, only 1 person out of these 10000 will have pancreatic cancer, so there will only be only 1 true positive result. However, since the test has a 1\% error rate, amongst the 9999 people who get the test there will be 99 false positives (defined as people who do not have cancer but get a positive result anyway). Therefore, there will be 1 true positive and 99 false positives. This means that anyone who gets a positive result has a 99\% chance that the result is a false positive, and only a 1\% chance that it is a true positive. 

To make it easier to see, we can make a table of these numbers:

These false positives might seem harmless, but they often result not only in anxiety for the patient but may also result in potentially harmful interventions such as scanning with radiation or unnecessary surgery. Therefore, doctors generally do not use tumour markers to check if people have cancer. 

 

Screening for depression

The prevalence of clinical depression in young people is around 17\%, making it the single most common serious medical condition amongst young people. Whilst there are many excellent treatment options available, including services like Mood Gym specifically targeted at young people, depression often goes unrecognised and people do not think to go to the doctor for it. Depression can be diagnosed using the PHQ-9 questionnaire, where a score of 11 or more (or thoughts of suicide alone) has an accuracy of around 80\% for diagnosing clinical depression. 

2. Make a table to figure out the chance of a positive test on the PHQ-9 questionnaire being a true positive. Do you think this makes universal screening for depression appropriate? 

 

How probability can save you money: Insurance premiums

As a high school student, you may already be driving, or be thinking about driving soon. As such, you may well be aware how expensive car insurance can be for a young person.

1. See how much you would pay for comprehensive car insurance per year if you were to drive your parents' car, using an online insurance calculator. 

Why is it so expensive? Because insurers know that young people are at much higher risk than older adults of having a car accident. For example, the graph below shows the rate of hospitalisations per 100000 people. 

2. What do you think are the factors which make younger drivers so much more likely to have a car crash?

In calculating your insurance premium (how much you pay for insurance), insurers want to ensure they are charging you the right price. If it is too expensive, you will end up getting insurance with another company instead. If it is too cheap, then the insurance company will end up losing money because the costs of car crashes will be more than the money they make from car insurance. 

In trying to figure out the "right price" for insurance, the insurance companies hire an "actuary". Actuaries are part of the mathematical elite, using complex probability calculations to figure out the long-term risk of events like car crashes or natural disasters happening. Having such useful mathematical skills makes actuaries highly sought-after by a range of companies, and the profession has been rated as the best job of 2013 based on its high income, good work environment and balanced lifestyle. 

Whilst we won't get into the real-life complex calculations, let's make our own simple model and see how well it works. 

1. How much do you think your parent's car is worth? 

2. What is your risk of a major car crash per year? Use the tables below to calculate the approximate yearly risk of a car crash for your age group. 

This table shows the number of crashes per age group:

This table shows the number of licence-holders per age group:

3. Multiply your risk by the estimated cost of the crash. To keep it simple, we'll assume that the cost of the crash is simply the cost of replacing your car. 

4. The number you have is the approximate amount of money that an insurance company would need to charge to "break even" on your insurance policy. How does it compare with the figure you got from the actual insurance calculator? Can you think of why the two numbers would be different? What costs does your estimate not include?

What happens if you drive below the speed limit?

Recently, some insurance companies have started to offer an interesting deal for drivers. If you agree to have a "black box" put in your car, the insurance company can gather data on your driving habits, and charge you insurance premiums according to how you drive. Let's calculate how knowing your driving habits might allow you to have cheaper insurance. 

A recent Road and Maritime Services paper points out that "In urban areas, exceeding the speed limit by 5 km/h doubles the likelihood of a casualty crash and each additional increase in speed by 5 km/h further doubles the risk". Speeding contributes to around 40 percent of fatal crashes. If we extrapolate this to non-fatal crashes as well, we could argue that you can reduce your risk of a crash by around 40 percent if you do not speed. 

Let's say that your "black box" shows that you never exceed the speed limit. 

5. If we assume that this reduces your risk of crashes by 40 percent, what is your new risk of a car crash?

6. Using the previous method of calculating insurance premiums, what would your insurance premium be now?

7. If the black box shows that your driving habits are identical to an older driver, should you receive the same insurance premium as them? Why or why not? 

8. If "black boxes" became popular, what would happen to the insurance premiums of drivers who did not sign up for a "black box"?  

9. Would you want to sign up for a black box for your car insurance? Why or why not? 

10. Are there any other things that insurance companies could do to identify young drivers who are at lower risk, to reduce the cost of their insurance? 

 

How probability can get you a job 

11. Can you find another job where you think probability would play an important role in decision making. How do you think probability would be used in this setting?