topic badge

11.05 Comparisons using standard deviation

Worksheet
Comparisons of two data sets
1

Consider the test results for four Geography classes, labelled as Class W, Class X, Class Y and Class Z:

Rank the classes from largest standard deviation to smallest standard deviation.

2

The mean income of people in Canada is \$43\,000. This is the same as the mean income of people in Germany. The standard deviation of Canada is greater than the standard deviation of Germany.

In which country is there likely to be the greatest difference between the incomes of the rich and poor?

3

Consider the following data sets:

  • Set A: \, 2,\, 4,\, 5,\, 8,\, 8,\, 9,\, 9,\, 9,\, 10,\, 10,\, 10,\, 11,\, 12,\, 15

  • Set B: \ 2,\, 2,\, 3,\, 4,\, 5,\, 5,\, 6,\, 7,\, 9,\, 11,\, 13,\, 13,\, 14,\, 15
a

Complete the following table. Round values to one decimal place where necessary.

RangeInterquartile rangeSample standard deviation
Set A
Set B
b

Which data set has more variability?

c

Is range a useful measure to compare variability for these two sets? Explain your answer.

4

The scores obtained by two classes are given below:

  • Red Class: \, 55,\, 57,\, 49,\, 58,\, 68,\, 57,\, 60,\, 53,\, 56,\, 51

  • Blue Class: \ 53,\, 59,\, 52,\, 49,\, 59,\, 49,\, 58,\, 57,\, 48,\, 54

a

Complete the following table. Round all values to two decimal places where necessary.

MeanSample standard deviation
Red Class
Blue Class
b

Which class performed better? Explain your answer.

c

Which class produced more consistent results? Explain your answer.

5

Two companies record the wait time for calls to their customer hotlines over 10 calls. The recorded values are given below in minutes:

  • Company X: \, 3.1,\, 2.1,\, 3.1,\, 3.2,\, 3.0,\, 2.6,\, 3.8,\, 2.7,\, 2.5,\, 3.5
  • Company Y: \, 2.2,\, 3.1,\, 3.0,\, 2.5,\, 3.0,\, 3.2,\, 3.2,\, 2.7,\, 2.5,\, 2.5
a

Complete the following table. Round all values to two decimal places.

Mean (mins)Sample standard deviation (mins)
Company X
Company Y
b

Which company generally has better response times?

c

Which company has more consistent response times?

6

The life of two brands of batteries are tested using a sample of 10 batteries from each brand. Their battery lives (in hours) are shown below:

  • Brand X: \, 23.3,\, 19.7,\, 20.7,\, 25.3,\, 22.5,\, 19.1,\, 20.0,\, 20.7,\, 20.7,\, 20.9
  • Brand Y: \, 23.2,\, 27.5,\, 25.0,\, 24.5,\, 22.7,\, 29.8,\, 22.9,\, 26.0,\, 26.4,\, 22.6
a

Complete the following table. Round all values to one decimal place.

Mean (hrs)Sample standard deviation (hrs)
Brand X
Brand Y
b

Which brand produces batteries that generally last longer?

c

Which brand produces batteries that are more consistent?

7

Two machines A and B are producing chocolate bars with the following mean and standard deviation for the weight of the bars:

a

What does a comparison of the mean of the two machines tell us?

b

What does a comparison of the standard deviation of the two machines tell us?

MachineMean (g)Standard deviation (g)
\text{A}521.6
\text{B}550.65
8

Two friends compete in triple jump and the distance of 20 jumps were recorded. The mean and standard deviation for the jumps are shown below:

a

What does a comparison of the mean of the two friends tell us?

b

What does a comparison of the standard deviation of the two friends tell us?

JumperMean (m)Standard deviation (m)
\text{Fred}12.40.8
\text{Tracy}11.60.5
9

Two friends compete in 100 m sprints and the time to complete 50 sprints were recorded. The mean and standard deviation for the sprints are shown below.

a

What does a comparison of the mean of the two friends tell us?

b

What does a comparison of the standard deviation of the two friends tell us?

RunnerMean (s)Standard deviation (s)
\text{Quentin}13.21.2
\text{Hannah}14.60.75
10

Points scored by two friends over 10 rounds of a game are displayed below:

  • Georgia: \, 10,\, 31,\, 23,\, 6,\, 5,\, 38,\, 18,\, 19,\, 15,\, 21
  • Mario: \, 52,\, 51,\, 77,\, 40,\, 61,\, 53,\, 60,\, 81,\, 52,\, 82
a

Complete the following table. Round all values to one decimal place.

MeanPopulation standard deviation
Georgia
Mario
b

Explain what the statistics calculated in part (a) tell us about the two players.

11

Two cricketers compare the mean and standard deviation of their runs made per match. They conclude that Ivan is a more consistent batter but Bianca generally scores more runs per match.

Compare the mean and standard deviation of the two players.

12

Seven millionaires with an average net wealth of \$41 million with a standard deviation of \$8 million are having a party. Suddenly Warren Buffet, who has a net wealth estimated to be \$34 billion, walks into the room.

a

Find the new average net wealth in the room. Round your answer to the nearest million.

b

Will the new standard deviation be higher, lower or unchanged from before?

c

Will the mode be higher, lower or unchanged from before if at least two of the millionaires have the same net wealth?

d

Will the range be higher, lower or unchanged from before?

13

Luke, a cricketer, has made scores of 51, 25, 99, 35 and 90 in his first five innings this season. In his sixth innings, he scores a duck or 0. Describe how this new score affected the following:

a

His season batting average.

b

The standard deviation of his scores.

c

His median score.

d

The range of his scores.

14

The table shows the heart rate data of a group of people after exercise:

Height of stepStepping rateHeart rate
\text{Short step}\text{Slow}92
\text{Short step}\text{Slow}96
\text{Short step}\text{Medium}105
\text{Short step}\text{Medium}106
\text{Short step}\text{Fast}121
\text{Short step}\text{Fast}125
\text{Tall step}\text{Slow}101
\text{Tall step}\text{Slow}103
\text{Tall step}\text{Medium}119
\text{Tall step}\text{Medium}124
\text{Tall step}\text{Fast}127
\text{Tall step}\text{Fast}130
a

Complete the table. Round all values to one decimal place.

Height of stepDataSlowMediumFast
\text{Short step}\text{Mean heart rate}94.0
\text{Standard deviation of heart rate}2.0
\text{Tall step}\text{Mean heart rate}
\text{Standard deviation of heart rate}
b

Which of the combinations of step height and stepping rate generated the highest heart rate?

c

Which of the combination of step height and stepping rate showed the least variability?

Sign up to access Worksheet
Get full access to our content with a Mathspace account

Outcomes

VCMSP372 (10a)

Calculate and interpret the mean and standard deviation of data and use these to compare data sets. Investigate the effect of individual data values including outliers, on the standard deviation

What is Mathspace

About Mathspace