topic badge

1.03 Checking reasonableness

Lesson

Check reasonableness

So far we have been finding exact answers to arithmetical operations, and learning how to perform them quickly and accurately is an important skill. An equally important skill is being able to reasonably estimate answers - this is useful not only when speed is more important than accuracy, but also to check calculations to see if they are roughly on the right track.

Suppose you and two friends had to split more than \$10 evenly between you. One of your friends counts it out, and by the end you have \$1.50. You would be able to rightly complain that something went wrong - if all three of you ended up with only \$1.50 then the total amount that was split would have been less than \$5 to begin with.

Importantly, you don't need to know exactly how much you started with to check the reasonableness of this calculation. Instead you can let your friends know that they need to try again - and you would watch a lot more closely this time.

One of the most important tools we use when checking reasonableness is rounding the numbers to make the calculation easier. This produces an estimate - the more you round, the more inaccurate your estimate becomes. If you round the numbers up, then the estimate will be larger than the true answer, and if you round down, the estimate will be smaller.

The more you round, the less reasonable your calculation becomes - rounding each number in 6\times6 to the nearest 10 makes 10\times10, and 100 is not a good estimate for 6\times6=36.

Also, if you round some numbers up and some numbers down, you'll still produce an estimate, but you won't be able to easily tell if it's an overestimate or an underestimate. Rounding each number in \\ 21\times19 to the nearest 10 makes 20\times20=400, which is a good overestimate. Rounding each number in 18\times23 to the nearest 10 also makes 20\times20=400, which is a good underestimate.

To find a reasonable estimate for a calculation, try rounding the numbers to the nearest 10, the nearest 100, or some other place value. This will make the calculation easier and give you a rough idea of what the answer should be.

If you round all the numbers up, your new calculation will be an overestimate (larger than the original).

If you round all the numbers down, your new calculation will be an underestimate (smaller than the original).

Examples

Example 1

Is this a reasonable statement? "67-29 is close to 40"?

Worked Solution
Create a strategy

Round each number to the nearest 10, then evaluate.

Apply the idea

Rounding off each number to the nearest 10 would give us: 70-30 which is equal to 40.

So "67-29 is close to 40" is a resonable statement.

Example 2

Is this statement accurate? "4\times 58 will be less than 200."

Worked Solution
Create a strategy

Round the larger number up and down to the nearest 10 and evaluate the expression.

Apply the idea

Rounding down 58 to the nearest 10 will give us 50.

\displaystyle 4\times50\displaystyle =\displaystyle 200Evaluate the multiplication

Rounding up 58 to the nearest 10 will give us 60.

\displaystyle 4\times60\displaystyle =\displaystyle 240Evaluate the multiplication

We know that 58 is larger than 50 and smaller than 60. So we can say that 4\times58 will be more than 200 but less than 240.

So the statement "4\times58 will be less than 200" is not accurate.

Idea summary

To find a reasonable estimate for a calculation, try rounding the numbers to the nearest 10, the nearest 100, or some other place value. This will make the calculation easier and give you a rough idea of what the answer should be.

If you round all the numbers up, your new calculation will be an overestimate (larger than the original).

If you round all the numbers down, your new calculation will be an underestimate (smaller than the original).

Outcomes

MA4-4NA

compares, orders and calculates with integers, applying a range of strategies to aid computation

What is Mathspace

About Mathspace